I do have a longer opinions on them but I am just going to name them worst to best as of moment of me writing thes. While making short point. This ranking fluctuates depending on a moon. Also, not every pros and cons are equal
1) Kiyoko: All about the champion, a lot of interesting dialogue and interaction, developted, half of Kinu content, pregnancy, all different holiday events, just a lot of stuff that I like
Cons: Seems removed from the rest of the story, only has penetrative sex in mind, not recrutiable if you are not willing to fuck, can only be lovers with her, kinus other 50 percent
2) Arona: 2 fun paths and a lot of variation with her content, a somewhat unique morality compas compared to rest of the companions, Dom and Sub paths both feel unique, does not lose her edge when subbing for player, a character with a dick that you can dominate while bottoming (especially nice when I am playing femdon vagina weilding characters), has good mix of good and bad qualities, polymorus but put so much emphasis on how awsome we are, her pregnancy scenes are top tire, relationship does not develop of those of the lovers out of nowhere (this is especially nice), has a lot of character quirks that elevate her above just being an orc
Needs some more fleshing out, more companion interactions and can not get pregnant, dom route lacks somewhat for vagina only champions (especially in how many ways she can get you pregnant in sub route)
3)Brienne: All about the champion, has a lot of sweet interaction with the champion, powerfull yet sweet, great design, pregnancy content, genderbend somewhat, domming the dom is top tire stuff
Looses a lot things that made Brint unique, feels like she is in no way related to him, a lot of her sex scenes feels samey compared to a lot what her writer writes, kind of misses the mark on genderbend part, to wish fullfilment in some aspects, kind of weird how she is okay fooling around with girls with vagina but not with man.
4)Berwyn: A confident femboy is always great, big dick as a plus (some people may find it to big), great ass, acts like a man despite his looks, hid dom content is nice, pregnancy is sweet, like that we can incurige him to have sex with cait, same as arona in being in open relationsho but somewhat making things between us feel special (especially pregnancy thing)
Lacking in content, we are forced to let him live with us even after he tried to rape us, I have to admit dick could be a tiny bit smaller, people wanting to make him a girl (not a problem with him I know), wish he could be a sub (buttslut) and have some femdom content where we dom his dick, I want to be a big spoon in the bed
5)Quint: Ey a twink is always nice, bunny boys>girls, fun sex scenes, really feels like a fuck buddy to who you can compare your sexual conqusts, has dom and sub content, sub content where you can dom his dick no less, interesting to talk to, a dorky personality on a confident boy is always fun, great personality with many nuances, like that there are multyply ways we can deal with him being a former cultist. being able to act somewhat questionable with someone is always a plus, hope that we could stay fuck buddies if we continue fucking and not be forced into relationship with him
While fan of open relationships, I do prefer more of those only for you types, I want to big spoon once in bed with a guy, cheating motherfucker, not really attracted to him romanticly, lacks in content, , I would like to say that he has some gray morality to him but I am not sure if it is intended.
6)Cait: Great healer, friend, fun sex scenes, always commening on the state of the story, interacts a lot with others through the game, fun sex scenes, I assume that we have an option to refuse her advances
Way to simple for how much pressence she has, her warnign screen is laughable, feels like you can not escape her if you do not like her (she finds her way in a lot of content), hate that we can not refuse her anal virginity arter beating her starting quest and choosing sex option, like I really hate that, can not get pregnant
7)Etheryn; Has 3 paths you can chose (master/slave, friends with benefits, lovers), nice to see grow or degrade, fun to lift up mentally and physically, fun to bully mentally and physically, feels nice to have an companion where our champion can act corrupt, has a lot of fun non sexual content, a lot of dialogue of her on commenting on events and lore, acts feminine with a dick,
Her confidence gauge is missleading, game expects you to fuck her if you want her functional in the party, hard to keep her confidence gauge low outside of special events, starting to lack in that abusive/sadistic content, it feels like game is trying to hard to make me care for her
8)Good bro if you are not fucking him, fun to interact with, nice sex for those who are into him, goes against sterotipical macho behavior that his looks paint him as but still retaining his edge, writer keeps content even wiht his female counter part
Hate how our character interacts next to him, acts like love struck school girl that never had expirienced sex, kind of ruins the image of having a bro if every 3 sentences our character confesses there love to him, honestly this is probably only reason he is this love, not a fan of open relationships if we are sub in it.
9)Azzy Fun, has a lots of content related to her and her people, has really nice romance with a knight, takes some weight of my shoulder by milking brienne (good to see that some part of brint is still left in there)
Not into her whole design, not into egg laying content, not into poison stuff, kind of boring character honestly, feels like she does not fulfill any specific character niche, she gets a lot of similar content from other girls but not really anything to call her own, I just find her boring which is a biggest determent here
Atugia- give her more content so that I have something more substantial to comment on.