1. Arona: She's a very flexible companion. Dominant or submissive, cock cunt and ass, has pregnancy content, does threesomes, melee combatant, fun fun fun.
2. Brienne: Big strong women with soft gooey centres are my weakness, so sue me. Having big milky boobs and a very enjoyable family certainly helps. Sorry Brint old boy.
3. Etheryn: Has strong character development, variety of sex scenes and satiates my desire for submissive girls with cocks. Also love her personal quests.
4. Kiyoko: A lot of the content associated with her is very fiddly and hard to proc correctly. But she's still the game's O.G. pregnancy fetish girl and I really appreciate that. Plus her having a child with us who's a character in her own right is much appreciated even if, again, it's a bit fiddly about when and how it procs.
5. Cait: I feel bad about this, because I don't dislike Cait. I just kind of have gotten tired of her I guess, since I played this game since launch and she's been a constant in it, leaving plenty of time to watch all her scenes to the point of meaninglessness. Also her expansion content is very underwhelming especially with that one girl we have to pay 15,000 for the PRIVILEDGE of a rather underwhelming pregnancy that goes nowhere.
6. Azzyran: I admit I don't really think about her much. She's perfectly fine, but when I already have Brienne, Atugia AND Arona, there's not much room for yet another melee warrior. Speaking of...
7. Atugia: Bland. "Small girl who can take her head off" is not really that special in the crowded lineup of companions. Sorry again.