What content would you like added?

Mizukage

Well-Known Member
Mar 16, 2021
52
72
34
Being able to eventually de-dick Arona and Etheryn would be sweet. Domming Izma so thoroughly in CoC1 that she was willing to lose it was great, so seeing that repeated with Arona would be top-shelf.

Its my understanding that Etheryn's plumbing getting altered is not something their writer is interested in pursuing as an option for Etheryn's character.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeyJune

WolframL

Well-Known Member
Feb 12, 2020
3,610
5,141
42
Ryn and Arona are both Savin's characters so yeah, totally not happening ever. Bear in mind also that Ryn does not want to remove her penis (and is horrified when the Champion tries suggesting it) and Arona's backstory explains the lengths she went to in order to get hers in the first place. In both instances, it's a fundamental part of who they are as people. The one dream where the Champion can remove Ryn's penis requires seriously high Corruption and reads like a rape. Hint hint.
 
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
Ryn and Arona are both Savin's characters so yeah, totally not happening ever. Bear in mind also that Ryn does not want to remove her penis (and is horrified when the Champion tries suggesting it) and Arona's backstory explains the lengths she went to in order to get hers in the first place. In both instances, it's a fundamental part of who they are as people. The one dream where the Champion can remove Ryn's penis requires seriously high Corruption and reads like a rape. Hint hint.
Alright already. The first two people saying that's confirmed not happening were enough. Also, subtweeting? Very tacky.
 

HalfALifeLol

Well-Known Member
Feb 12, 2018
246
323
32
Alright already. The first two people saying that's confirmed not happening were enough. Also, subtweeting? Very tacky.
Fair warning, as popular as calling for futa-ing a character is the inverse is sometimes treated as evil-incarnate by some folks.

General rule of thumb though is that its very much up to the writer and most do not react badly to asking (once), its more passionate fans that react like angry lava porcupines to the question.

Savin is very much in the hard no camp while Wsan is sort of the opposite, to describe something of a spectrum (and even then, most of the established writers have a varied enough portfolio that I hesitate to call that a solid guess). Although I do seem to recall one of the writers (I think it was Savin themselves), mentioning once that its relative difficulty in terms of scope was the real primary reason why it is not done that often.

All that being said, while Arona does have the plumbing for preg content, I seem to recall reading somewhere that Savin is also not a fan of writing NPC Preg stuff (although as a dev they are super willing to play ball with whatever other writers want to do with their stuff, so great credit to them there). So while I wistfully would like to have her mothering a brood, it will likely never happen.

Need to check who wrote Viv though, since thats one I would love to see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Prof. Hyde White
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
Fair warning, as popular as calling for futa-ing a character is the inverse is sometimes treated as evil-incarnate by some folks.

General rule of thumb though is that its very much up to the writer and most do not react badly to asking (once), its more passionate fans that react like angry lava porcupines to the question.

Savin is very much in the hard no camp while Wsan is sort of the opposite, to describe something of a spectrum (and even then, most of the established writers have a varied enough portfolio that I hesitate to call that a solid guess). Although I do seem to recall one of the writers (I think it was Savin themselves), mentioning once that its relative difficulty in terms of scope was the real primary reason why it is not done that often.

All that being said, while Arona does have the plumbing for preg content, I seem to recall reading somewhere that Savin is also not a fan of writing NPC Preg stuff (although as a dev they are super willing to play ball with whatever other writers want to do with their stuff, so great credit to them there). So while I wistfully would like to have her mothering a brood, it will likely never happen.

Need to check who wrote Viv though, since thats one I would love to see.
Regardless I've learned my lesson. This is a super serious porn game and just throwing out ideas in the "what would you like to see thread" is illegal unless you've read all the backstory and know all about the writer's personal fetishes. Reminds me why I've made at max like 7 posts here.
 

WolframL

Well-Known Member
Feb 12, 2020
3,610
5,141
42
Also, subtweeting? Very tacky.
Oh get over yourself. The board notifies you of replies to any topic you post in; I saw no reason to quote the immediately prior post.

This is a super serious porn game and just throwing out ideas in the "what would you like to see thread" is illegal unless you've read all the backstory and know all about the writer's personal fetishes.
Surprisingly, people on these boards can be salty. Especially when it's a topic that comes up with some regularity and people who do post here regularly see it all the time and forget that people who have just popped in might not know how often said topics get raised.

All that being said, while Arona does have the plumbing for preg content, I seem to recall reading somewhere that Savin is also not a fan of writing NPC Preg stuff
Savin himself would disagree. ;)

Need to check who wrote Viv though, since thats one I would love to see.
Balak
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tide Hunter
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
Surprisingly, people on these boards can be salty. Especially when it's a topic that comes up with some regularity and people who do post here regularly see it all the time and forget that people who have just popped in might not know how often said topics get raised.
Regardless the goodwill I had built up after binging this game has been crushed and my desire to further interact with this community has been excised. And for the record, it did not notify me of more posts in this thread, I only saw it because I left the tab open. So you'll have to forgive me for drawing a conclusion from that.
 

zagzig

Well-Known Member
Feb 26, 2021
795
1,066
Regardless the goodwill I had built up after binging this game has been crushed and my desire to further interact with this community has been excised. And for the record, it did not notify me of more posts in this thread, I only saw it because I left the tab open. So you'll have to forgive me for drawing a conclusion from that.
That's probably for the best, you don't want to be around when everyone makes fun of this post.

The goodwill I had built up has been crushed and my desire to further interact with this community has been excised. YOU WILL NEVER SEE ME AROUND THESE PARTS AGAIN.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Prof. Hyde White
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
That's probably for the best, you don't want to be around when everyone makes fun of this post.

The goodwill I had built up has been crushed and my desire to further interact with this community has been excised. YOU WILL NEVER SEE ME AROUND THESE PARTS AGAIN.
Yeah, taking a second look that did sound pretty dumb lmao. I'll leave it up cuz I ain't a bitch tho.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zagzig

Mizukage

Well-Known Member
Mar 16, 2021
52
72
34
For a minute I thought you had misspelled exorcised, then spell check told me that excised is a real word so i guess I learned something new today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Prof. Hyde White

Tide Hunter

Well-Known Member
May 4, 2019
891
1,195
Regardless I've learned my lesson. This is a super serious porn game and just throwing out ideas in the "what would you like to see thread" is illegal unless you've read all the backstory and know all about the writer's personal fetishes. Reminds me why I've made at max like 7 posts here.
It isn't that people take it super seriously (though there are several aspects which people do take seriously), but the main reason why things like that often get heavily shot down is because, well, I feel like "de-dick Etheryn" (along with "de-dick Berwyn") is one of the most common requests made in this thread and the Gripes thread. Often it's recommended for people to search for things themselves. This site has a search feature, and while it's honestly pretty bad a lot of the time, it can still let you look for if this topic has been discussed before, and get answers to your questions and requests that way. If you can't find it in the search, then ask away.
 

Wsan

Scientist
Creator
Jan 8, 2016
1,731
4,064
The reason people here don't like de-dicking is because it's viewed (and unfortunately, often done) as character assassination, turning what is usually a brash, confident and self-assured character with a dick into a mewling bitch who only wants some more dickings. I won't comment on that since I myself have written the most pandery companion in the game, but I personally only plan on writing it as part of a character arc.

And before anyone says "well yes but the meaningful character arc was implied", it wasn't. For every 1 person asking for Etheryn dedicking as part of a grand thing to make her feel like a woman or whatever thing they've come up with, there's 99 asking just because they want her dickless so they can fuck her like every other woman in the game. Just look at any blog post for evidence.

It's a somewhat unfortunate situation because both sides get boiled down to garbage, and the issue comes up very often so it's become a sore point.

Additionally, I should point this out, the vast, vast majority of our paying customers like dickgirls, and want more of them. We've polled this pretty extensively. There is no silent majority out there waiting for us to turn the game into a utopian harem paradise, not that anyone here has implied that.
 
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
It isn't that people take it super seriously (though there are several aspects which people do take seriously), but the main reason why things like that often get heavily shot down is because, well, I feel like "de-dick Etheryn" (along with "de-dick Berwyn") is one of the most common requests made in this thread and the Gripes thread. Often it's recommended for people to search for things themselves. This site has a search feature, and while it's honestly pretty bad a lot of the time, it can still let you look for if this topic has been discussed before, and get answers to your questions and requests that way. If you can't find it in the search, then ask away.
Well sorry, I guess. I honestly figured that in a thread that has 162 pages no one would care, much less get salty.
 
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
The reason people here don't like de-dicking is because it's viewed (and unfortunately, often done) as character assassination, turning what is usually a brash, confident and self-assured character with a dick into a mewling bitch who only wants some more dickings. I won't comment on that since I myself have written the most pandery companion in the game, but I personally only plan on writing it as part of a character arc.

And before anyone says "well yes but the meaningful character arc was implied", it wasn't. For every 1 person asking for Etheryn dedicking as part of a grand thing to make her feel like a woman or whatever thing they've come up with, there's 99 asking just because they want her dickless so they can fuck her like every other woman in the game. Just look at any blog post for evidence.

It's a somewhat unfortunate situation because both sides get boiled down to garbage, and the issue comes up very often so it's become a sore point.

Additionally, I should point this out, the vast, vast majority of our paying customers like dickgirls, and want more of them. We've polled this pretty extensively. There is no silent majority out there waiting for us to turn the game into a utopian harem paradise, not that anyone here has implied that.
My thought process was entirely just "oh wow, this game's cool now. CoC often had interesting directions you could take companions, I might as well piss into the wind about these characters I like." The fact that this is apparently a thing and that people actually have taken sides in it is just so divorced from anything I would have considered that it blows my mind.
 

HalfALifeLol

Well-Known Member
Feb 12, 2018
246
323
32
The reason people here don't like de-dicking is because it's viewed (and unfortunately, often done) as character assassination, turning what is usually a brash, confident and self-assured character with a dick into a mewling bitch who only wants some more dickings. I won't comment on that since I myself have written the most pandery companion in the game, but I personally only plan on writing it as part of a character arc.

And before anyone says "well yes but the meaningful character arc was implied", it wasn't. For every 1 person asking for Etheryn dedicking as part of a grand thing to make her feel like a woman or whatever thing they've come up with, there's 99 asking just because they want her dickless so they can fuck her like every other woman in the game. Just look at any blog post for evidence.

It's a somewhat unfortunate situation because both sides get boiled down to garbage, and the issue comes up very often so it's become a sore point.

Additionally, I should point this out, the vast, vast majority of our paying customers like dickgirls, and want more of them. We've polled this pretty extensively. There is no silent majority out there waiting for us to turn the game into a utopian harem paradise, not that anyone here has implied that.
....Glances at existing cast.

I feel like we hit utopian harem paradise a while back... Not really sure how their relative status as futas really affects that, heck Berwyn is an outright guy and he gives off enough Tsundere energy to power a small city by himself lol. With respect you sort of have to be ridiculously picky to be able to claim that the game doesn't at least have a character which caters to you specifically at this point.

Also, I'm curious who you mean by most pandery? If its Brienne then I need to reassess my previously negative opinion on pandering since she is sort of awesome and would be sufficient to make me a big fan of pandering.

Honestly though? As much as it pleases my own personal preferences, there is a reason I don't even mention it that often. It really seems like the only thing that gets consistently kink-shamed, which sort of sucks since I do like to think the community on here is largely pretty open and accepting beyond that. It being a rare treat and extremely unlikely, I can be totally cool with, its the outright hostility alot of folks display at the mention of it that leaves a really bad taste in my mouth. Which is sort of funky given that it is not the most unconventional fetish we have material addressing (glances at the ghosts, slaves and trees).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Prof. Hyde White
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
....Glances at existing cast.

I feel like we hit utopian harem paradise a while back... Not really sure how their relative status as futas really affects that.
Real talk, this. It just seems like a classic case of "stop not liking what I like". The only reason having the option would necessitate assassinating that character would be if is if it was written that way and writing it that way would defeat the whole purpose of doing it in the first place.
The literal only relevant fact put forth throughout all of this is Savin doesn't want to do it. The conversation had absolutely no reason to continue beyond that point. Any other justification given for why it won't/"""shouldn't""" happen is completely moot because that's the only thing that actually matters. If he doesn't want to pursue that avenue, he doesn't want to do it, and all that's worth is a shrug and an "oh well, at least I asked". Because getting up in arms about what kind of content is/isn't in a free porn game on the internet is a massive waste of time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Animalistic

The Observer

Scientist
FoE Mod
Aug 27, 2015
1,357
3,189
Some history about Izma:

Izma was never meant to have dedicking. The author was staunchly against having Izma dedicked. The community at the time so brutally and vociferously mobbed Izma's author until said author was run out of the community, then proceeded to shit all over their character by doing exactly that.

Bringing up Izma brings with it that entire train of baggage.
 
Dec 22, 2015
16
8
Some history about Izma:

Izma was never meant to have dedicking. The author was staunchly against having Izma dedicked. The community at the time so brutally and vociferously mobbed Izma's author until said author was run out of the community, then proceeded to shit all over their character by doing exactly that.

Bringing up Izma brings with it that entire train of baggage.
Well I didn't know that. My God, is there anything surrounding these games that doesn't have a massive history of insane community baggage I need to brush up on?
 
Last edited:

Animalistic

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2019
1,574
2,014
Some history about Izma:

Izma was never meant to have dedicking. The author was staunchly against having Izma dedicked. The community at the time so brutally and vociferously mobbed Izma's author until said author was run out of the community, then proceeded to shit all over their character by doing exactly that.

Bringing up Izma brings with it that entire train of baggage.
Now I feel guilty for enjoying it. I hope that the author is doing alright.

Hey
I don't have a massive history of insane community baggage you need to brush up on
YET
Nobody mobbed you for having MILF gob at middle of the town that people can not fuck? I am impressed.
 

ShifterDreams

Well-Known Member
Sep 18, 2015
513
278
now we have the new appearance screen and tfs are open to be made id love to see some more big cat tfs like a lion or tiger i think Leothran are basicly tiger/snow leopard sabretooth's so maybe a variation of them or a way to add fur patterns like full body stripes or spots and maybe a tiger race that is not anthro but have a human face/body with the rest tiger like including furred arms, pawed feet, tail, ears etc
and something other then tfs id like to see more outfits like a mage outfit that is not a apprentice robe or a kimono
and more weapons like a scythe or whip
and more catalysts like a arcane book or more totems
 

Alypia

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2016
1,374
3,617
Hey
I don't have a massive history of insane community baggage you need to brush up on
YET
You do have a massive history of insane community bulli though.

Fortunately, now that the interminably long appearance rework is finished, every one of us can admire Champ's thights. And it's all thanks to you.
 
Last edited:

Wint3rRyd3r

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
929
2,159
You do have a massive history of insane community bulli though.

Fortunately, now that the interminably long appearance rework is finished, every one of us can admire Champ's thights. And it's all thanks to you.

Thick thighs save lives. Come on get up, come on get down with the thiccness!

Where's my headpat Nakano option? He'd hate that and wouldn't be able to react how he wants. He's got such a stick up his ass, that messing with him is fun. Surely Takahiro could help us with the eternal quest to bully Nakano.
 

honeypony

Member
Jan 21, 2021
20
77
what about mermaids? I found very rare mentions. sorry if already discussed)
I think it would be great to have a transformation that gives you temporary external gills, like a newt, to be able to communicate with mermaids on their territory.
(the gills would fall off when the PC leaves the water area)
 

WolframL

Well-Known Member
Feb 12, 2020
3,610
5,141
42
what about mermaids? I found very rare mentions. sorry if already discussed)
I think it would be great to have a transformation that gives you temporary external gills, like a newt, to be able to communicate with mermaids on their territory.
Have you done the Rift content yet? There's already the seeds of something like this (except it's magical tattoos) that will allow you to breathe and communicate underwater, though that's implied future content rather than something implemented. Gardeford has mentioned there are plans for a 'blue whale mermaid' in the distant future so assuming that's still coming there will be more aquatic races eventually.
 
  • Like
Reactions: honeypony