Wait, what? Really? I admit I havent't played the game for a while, but I remember Being always utterly dominating fights... Plus he has amazing scenes if you are wubby bottom bitch hero. Hehe....
What exactly are cpeople complaining about concerning him?
I am just going to name all the complains I can remember.
So, hmmm where to start.
He is a male companion, so already he is lacking in appeeal with general audience.
His Busts do make him seem more untrustworthy than he actually is.
You gain corruption for refusing to help him.
He can come as an overtly sleezy asshole the first time you met him. And even after that, especially if you let him talk about your feminine companions.
He probably has the worst recruitment requirement in game, or at least tied to Arona (fetch quest are not fun).
His lust combat gimmick is not for everyone.
He has not received a major update in 2 years.
Because of his relationship mechanic, some people feel that they can not form a decent bond with him, specifically a romantic one.
my gripes:
He can feel a bit rapy with his liberal use of magic that is in essences ruffing.
As someone who likes topping guys, him being the only male companion that we can not top feels alienating.
His pregnancy content sucks.
I find his whole cultist shtic a missed opportunity when it comes to character progression. The game basically puts no blame on him for joining a cult that has never once, through the course of the game, presented as anything else than a wretched source of corruption. So having him be so guilt free (I checked out his inner thoughs) just rubs me the wrong way.
Still, I have to remind you that I like Quinn and that I would like more from him. I just wanted to make a somewhat comprehendive list.