I've been on the internet for decades. And I'll probably fall into the asshole category for saying so:
Truly suicidal people leave a note and kill themselves in silence, only to be found by family, a loved one or police weeks later. Those that cry out are looking for attention and never carry through.
You know, suicidal ideation can take many forms. Sometimes it takes a lot of courage to ask for help, and very little in return (a few words, someone who says they care what happens to you, even a stranger on the internet) to stop someone from killing themselves.
And I don't know about you, but I have enough energy to send a few words over the internet to anyone who seeks help because they are afraid they'll do something stupid. That's usually all it takes, anyway. Kind words and reminding the person who needs help about the little things they enjoy, or that they want to live for, even if just for one more day.
And what's wrong with
needing attention? Seriously, why the stigma about needing someone to talk to? Humans are social creatures. If they don't interact with others, their psyche's get damaged... so much so that it can lead them to kill themselves. People reaching out (even if they are misguided) is
good.
However a plea for help predicated in suicide or murder can in fact be generally ignored.
I deeply disagree with this. I don't know about murder, but so many people could have been stopped from killing themselves if only they'd just
reached out... or been listened to.
(And no, emotional blackmail like "If you leave me I'm killing myself" doesn't count as genuinely suicidal people reaching out, because it's, you know, emotional freaking blackmail.)
@Charm I guess our personal philosophies are just too different, but I needed to say this.