The demon cultists are no longer showing up.

[213Warrior]

They just stopped showing up after the abysal depths portion of the winter wolf quest, and Gweyr won't appear in Hawthorne.

 

[Gabranth]

You kicked them out.
Therefore, they're gone.

 

[WolframL]

To address the second thing, Gweyr doesn't just show up in town after the dungeon, you have to actively get Garret involved in order to bring her back. You know, like the journal entry for the quest at that point implies. Emphasis added.

Maybe you should check in with her family. There may be only one person left in the world who may be able to convince her to come home, as opposed to accepting her end.

 

[213Warrior]

To address the second thing, Gweyr doesn't just show up in town after the dungeon, you have to actively get Garret involved in order to bring her back. You know, like the journal entry for the quest at that point implies. Emphasis added.

I talked to Garret and Garth and waited 5 days.

 

[213Warrior]

You kicked them out.
Therefore, they're gone.

Unfortunate, thanks.

 

[Alypia]

On the bright side, if you're worried about making money, the valkyrie hunts should help fill the gap.

 

[WolframL]

I talked to Garret and Garth and waited 5 days.

Read the quest log again, you're missing an obvious step.

 

[Savin]

The cultists will also be reappearing in the next zone.