So... late to the party and probably necro'ing this thread buuuut... the older I get, the less invested I get in non-commited relationships... if this makes no sense, I'm not certain how else to put it other than I wanna see a way to earn Cait's exclusivity, but I want it to make sense...
(Yeah, yeah, deeper plot, slower burn, hurt/comfort and legit romance in a porn game... don't care)
Cait is the most invested I've been in a tutorial character in, like, ever... and by the gods if I (my PC) didn't get jealous and not allow the Minotaur dude in my party just because Cait showed some attraction to him...
TL;DR put me in the camp of wanting Cait exclusivity, but not through addiction to you/your cock/your cum... and I can't see this being an "easy" exclusivity, since PC would need to more or less try and get her to pick between her faith and him/herm/her... but gods I would LOVE a storyline where they slowly ACTUALLY fall in love and seek mutual exclusivity...
Uh, sorry for rambling rant and such